The Best Eyeliners of 2025

Rating: 5

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner: This eyeliner has garnered a strong reputation for its reliability and performance. The fine brush tip allows for precise application, making it suitable for both subtle lines and dramatic wings. Users appreciate its smudge-proof and transfer-resistant formula, which holds up well throughout the day, even in humid conditions. The satin finish adds a touch of elegance without appearing too harsh. While it is on the pricier side, many find the quality justifies the investment, especially for those seeking a dependable liquid eyeliner that truly stays put.

— Emily Johnson

Rating: 5

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil: NYX delivers a commendable product with this mechanical eye pencil. The intense pigmentation rivals that of liquid eyeliners, offering bold color payoff. Its creamy texture ensures smooth application without tugging on the delicate eye area. The retractable design eliminates the need for sharpening, adding to its convenience. Users have noted its impressive staying power, though those with oily eyelids might experience slight smudging after extended wear. Overall, it's an excellent budget-friendly option that doesn't compromise on quality.

— Sophia Brown

Rating: 5

e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner: True to its name, this eyeliner from e.l.f. offers remarkable staying power. Its ultra-pigmented formula ensures rich color with each stroke, and the creamy consistency allows for effortless application. Being both vegan and cruelty-free, it appeals to the ethically conscious consumer. Users have praised its ability to withstand long hours without smudging or fading. However, some have mentioned that the tip can become blunt over time, making precise application a bit challenging. Despite this minor drawback, its affordability and performance make it a popular choice.

— Sophia Brown

Rating: 4.8

Ownest 14 Colors Eyeliner Pen Set: This set stands out for its versatility and value. With 14 distinct pearl shades, it caters to those looking to experiment with color in their makeup routine. The eyeliners are lauded for their easy application and blendability, allowing users to create both bold and subtle looks. Their long-lasting formula ensures that the color remains vibrant throughout the day. Additionally, their multi-purpose nature means they can double up as eyeshadows or highlighters, offering more bang for your buck. Some users have noted that certain shades require layering to achieve full opacity, but overall, it's a fantastic set for creative makeup enthusiasts.

— Emily Johnson

Rating: 4.8

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner with Built-in Sharpener: Revlon's ColorStay line has been a staple for many, and this pencil eyeliner is no exception. Its waterproof formula ensures longevity, making it suitable for all-day wear without frequent touch-ups. The built-in sharpener is a thoughtful addition, ensuring the tip remains precise for detailed application. Users appreciate its smooth glide, which reduces the risk of skipping or uneven lines. While it's predominantly smudge-proof, individuals with oily skin might notice minimal smudging after prolonged wear. Nonetheless, its combination of quality, convenience, and affordability solidifies its place among top eyeliner choices.

— Emma Davis